Best Ice Cream, Froyo and Gelato in Kingston

Best Frozen Summer Treat, Kingston, OntarioLabour Day is finally here, which means that another summer has officially come and gone. Those long days requiring refuge in sub-zero air conditioning, a refreshing dip in the lake and enjoying frozen treats to beat the heat will soon be behind us. On the other hand, it’s not as though ice cream, frozen yogurt (froyo) and gelato ever go out of season. And what a season it has been for enthusiasts of frozen, sugary treats in Kingston. Our downtown has welcomed a handful of new temptations including Menchie’s, Marble Slab, and Cold Stone Creamery, while longstanding favourites such as White Mountain and Mio Gelato continue to draw the hungry masses. With all the variety the Limestone City has to offer, this week’s poll question asks:
[poll id=”125″]
Save for White Mountain, who traditionally closes their doors during the off season, all of the parlours competing in this week’s poll remain open during winter months. This is great news for those who simply cannot get enough, and can’t go without their sugar fix when the snow banks begin to pile high over our heads. Judging from the healthy lineups we’ve seen inside all of these establishments over the past few months, it’s really hard to determine who the definitive winner is. While Menchie’s grand opening has yet to lose any steam, White Mountain continues to enjoy line ups the extend out their door, and friends of Movies in the Square remain faithful to Mia Gelato and Marble Slab.  With Tim Horton’s diving scoop-first in the ice cream game, do our wallets and stomachs have room for any new competitors?

What makes one scoop better than the others? Are low-fat options, wild and experimental flavours, the ability to customize your treat or traditional flavors (ie chocolate and vanilla) the best way to determine a winner? Whatever the case may be, one thing is for certain, Kingstonians love delicious frozen treats.  What’s your favorite?

Thanks to mackenziephoto for today’s delicious shot.

Harvey Kirkpatrick

Harvey Kirkpatrick is Kingstonist's Co-Founder. His features curiously explore urban planning, what if scenarios, the local food scene and notable Kingstonians. Loves playing tourist and listening to rap music. Learn more about Harvey...

8 thoughts on “Best Ice Cream, Froyo and Gelato in Kingston

  • Come on, this shouldn't even be close. Mio Gelato is head and shoulders above the rest. The range, the quality and the price are all excellent.

    • Earlier in the week I would have bet the farm that White Mountain was going to win. Seems as though Mio Gelato's fans heard your call. They're narrowly pulling ahead. Exciting to see so much excitement for our local, independent ice cream and gelato hangouts.

      • I agree, and the main thing is that Marble Slab and Cold Stone (AKA the Corporate Enemies of Real Local Ice-Cream) are well-beaten.

  • I voted White Mountain, but really it's any place that carries Slicker's ice cream. Their "Campfire" is a toasted marshmallow flavour, complete with burnt marshmallow bits. You might have to take a drive out to the new dairy in Sydenham, but it's worth it.

Leave a Reply

You cannot copy content from this page, please share the link instead!