Weekly Poll: Re-Thinking Riding Boundary Lines

Re-Thinking Riding Boundary Lines, Kingston and the Islands Created in 1966, the electoral district known as Kingston and the Islands has been a stronghold for the federal Liberal party for 25 years, since 1988 to be exact.  In recent times, the district’s population has inched above 125,000, while the Federal Electoral Boundaries Commission calculates the average population of federal electoral ridings at 106,000.  This discrepancy, paired with recommendations stemming from a review of electoral districts that occurs every 10 years, has led to widespread speculation about whether or not boundary lines for Kingston and the Islands should be redrawn.  The Commission’s report makes the following recommendations:

The electoral district of LANARK—FRONTENAC is composed of Lanark County and Frontenac County, excluding the Township of Frontenac Islands and that part of the City of Kingston lying north of Highway 401. It has a population of 98,409, which is 7.35% below the provincial quota.  The electoral district of KINGSTON AND THE ISLANDS is composed of the boundaries from the 2003 representation order, less that part of the City of Kingston lying north of Highway 401. It has a population of 116,996, which is 10.15% above the provincial quota.

In case you don’t have your current electoral map handy, the recommendations would essentially shift the northern boundary of Kingston and the Islands’ riding down to the 401, while the area north of the highway would become a part of the Lanark-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington.  Accordingly, this week’s poll asks:

Do you support the proposed changes to our riding's boundaries?

  • No. (44%, 20 Votes)
  • Yes. (31%, 14 Votes)
  • Not sure. (22%, 10 Votes)
  • Something else entirely. (3%, 1 Votes)

Total Voters: 45

Loading ... Loading ...

If these proposed changes are adopted, their first test would be during the October 2015 federal election.  In that eventuality, for me, there really isn’t any change as I would still cast my vote in the Kingston and the Islands district.  Does that mean better representation for me and the other 116,996 constituents?  I’m not entirely sure.  That said, I am fearful that the recommendations could fragment the city by way of lumping the rural voters residing north of the 401 into a huge Conservative riding with vastly different needs and competing priorities.  While some have pointed out the benefits of having two MPs with a stake in representing Kingston, the advantages delicately teeter on whether or not the MPs are wearing the same stripes as one another, and their relation to the ruling party.

What are your thoughts on redrawing our riding’s boundary lines?  Do you think Ottawa should leave well enough alone, or do you support the changes as a result of better representation and a sharper focus on urban voters.  And what about our friends in rural Kingston? Are you keen on joining Lanark-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington, or not?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *